You can never have enough ice cream in the house. So why not save money by stocking up on the best Costco ice cream? The warehouse carries amazing sweet treats for the whole family, and their ice cream selection is vast. We’ve picked out the best and most popular flavors, so you know these will be worthwhile purchases.
8. Johnny Pops
First on the list of the best Costco ice cream is Johnny Pops. If you want a better option compared to other ice cream brands, then this is the perfect choice. Not only is an ice cream pop only 45 calories, but they’re vegan, gluten-free, peanut-free, organic, and kosher-friendly. Costco carries a variety of flavors like their Summer Sunrise and Rainbow Fruit Stacks, offering delicious, fruit-flavored pops that are guilt-free.
7. Island Way Sorbet Assortment
Another fruit option that is tastier and full of more nutrients than average ice cream options is Island Way Sorbet. One shell varies from 80 to 190 calories and is full of flavor. From choices like Coconut, Ruby Grapefruit, Mango, and Pomegranate, this is a favorite amongst Costco shoppers who have a sweet tooth but want a healthier option.
6. Fat Boy Ice Cream Sandwiches
Fat Boy ice cream sandwiches are one of the best Costco ice creams available. Made with premium vanilla ice cream smashed between two delicious chocolate wafers, Fat Boy knows how to create a creamy, flavorful ice cream bar. The box offers 18 bars of these delectable sandwiches at a great price, perfect for treating the whole family.
5. Yasso Greek Yogurt Bars
Speaking of healthier options, why not go for frozen yogurt instead? One of the best options at Costco is these Yasso bars. Most of their bars are low in calories, like this Cookies ‘n Cream flavor, for only 90 calories. Not only that, but they also have 5 grams of protein. Even with the lower calories, they’re packed with flavor, which has made them a new favorite amongst shoppers.
4. Mavens Durian Ice Cream
Mavens Durian ice cream is just as the name suggests, ice cream made with real durian. The fruit’s custard-like texture offers a rich taste that will quickly become a new favorite when shopping at Costco. Not only does it offer 10 grams of protein per container, but it also offers 2 grams of fiber. The brand also boasts that it doesn’t include artificial sweeteners, artificial colors or flavoring, nor high fructose corn syrup, so you don’t have to think twice about what you’re feeding your family.
3. Nestle Drumstick Ice Cream Sundae Cones
For larger families, one of the best Costco ice creams has to be Nestlé’s Drumsticks. The variety of packs offers 16 cones in either Vanilla Fudge, Vanilla Caramel, or just plain vanilla. Each flavor is dipped in a luxurious chocolate coating with crushed peanuts on the outside.
2. Häagen-Dazs
One of the most popular brands when it comes to the best ice cream is Häagen-Dazs, and the top item you can get at Costco is their ice cream bars. The creamy vanilla ice cream is dipped in deliciously luxurious chocolate with chopped almonds, creating a satisfying bite full of flavors and textures.
1. Kirkland Signature Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream
The number one best Costco ice cream to stock the freezer with is Kirkland Signature’s Super Premium Vanilla ice cream. While vanilla might seem like a boring choice compared to the rest on the list, this choice is just too hard to beat. Each box contains two half-gallon containers at an affordable price. The vanilla flavor is rich and creamy, offering a high-quality taste that impresses shoppers every time.
"We often receive complimentary products to review at Family Proof. Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team."