While it used to be relegated to backyard cookouts and special occasions, brisket has quickly moved to a mainstream staple. Unfortunately, brisket’s popularity raises its price tag.
Sam’s Club is currently selling boneless brisket at around $4.98 per pound, while Costco’s comparable brisket cut rings in at around $5.66 per pound. The gap reflects a broader trend where Sam’s Club often undercuts Costco on certain meat and household item prices.
It is important to note, though, that the choice between the two chains depends on what a family prizes most. Keep reading to learn more.
Meat Prices
The economics surrounding meat purchases are layered, and often can significantly impact a household once you get to the checkout line. For instance, a whole brisket typically weighs 10 to 16 pounds, so at $5-$5.50 per pound, it adds up quickly for a family meal or holiday cookout.
As for other meats in Sam’s Club and Costco, it follows a similar pattern. A boneless ribeye at Costco was around $25.53 per pound versus $22.46 per pound at Sam’s Club; boneless chicken breasts were around $3.39 per pound at Costco versus $2.77 per pound at Sam’s Club.
These small differences can turn into big impacts on grocery bills for households that buy in bulk or entertain often.
Other Grocery Prices
Cost and value are not identical, and there are plenty of other items where Costco has a lower price than Sam’s Club. Sam’s Club may be cheaper with olive oil, detergent, paper towels, and batteries, but Costco wins out on organic produce, dairy, and Kirkland Signature-specific items.
It’s important to take into account unit prices, membership benefits, and product mix when considering overall value and where to shop.
Non-Price Factors
Another thing to consider for families weighing the decision between Sam’s Club and Costco is the nonprice factors.
Costco appeals to customers due to its perceived product quality, larger selection of organic items, robust return and warranty policies, cash-back on certain memberships, and a popular food court.
Sam’s Club appeals to customers due to its lower prices on many staple items, possible lower costs for additional cardholders, and other fun benefits.
Choosing the Right Store For You
For parents and household shoppers planning meals, there are two main takeaways for your choice. If you prefer cutting immediate grocery costs on bulk meats and staple items, Sam’s Club often offers the lower per-pound and unit prices.
If you want store perks, a particular brand assortment, or services like return policies and fuel rewards, Costco may be justifiable for its premium in some categories.
Shoppers who want to get the most out of their money while still feeding their family quality food should consider a few factors when heading to the store. This includes unit prices on specific cuts and brands, typical weight of bulk items like brisket, membership costs, and other membership benefits.
It’s important to view and consider all of your options before committing to a store, especially those like Sam’s Club or Costco, as they require memberships to shop.
"We often receive complimentary products to review at Family Proof. Each product we feature has been independently selected and reviewed by our editorial team."